Air-Fryer New York Cheesecake Toasties

Sweet Munch Recipe

Air-Fryer New York Cheesecake Toasties

Air-fryer new york cheesecake toasties from Sweet Munch, built for hot pastry, molten centres, sticky sugar and proper dessert chaos.

This is what happens when a cheesecake and a toasted sandwich maker decide to collaborate without adult supervision. Cream cheese. Vanilla. Golden buttery bread. Sweet biscuit crunch.

Air-Fryer New York Cheesecake Toasties
Air-Fryer New York Cheesecake Toasties preparation stage

You’ll Need

4 thick slices brioche or white bread
150g cream cheese
2 tbsp icing sugar
1 tsp vanilla extract
25g digestive biscuits, crushed
25g butter, melted
For The Finish
1 tbsp icing sugar
Berry sauce or jam
Optional But Dangerous
White chocolate drizzle
Strawberries
Vanilla ice cream

Method

Preheat your air fryer to 180°C.

In a bowl, mix together the cream cheese, icing sugar, and vanilla extract until smooth.

Spread the mixture generously onto two slices of bread.

Sprinkle over the crushed digestive biscuits.

Top with the remaining bread slices and press lightly together.

Brush both sides with melted butter.

Place the toasties into the air fryer basket.

Air fry at 180°C for 5–7 minutes, carefully turning halfway through, until golden, crisp, and lightly

caramelised.

Allow to cool for 1 minute.

Dust lightly with icing sugar.

Serve with berry sauce or jam on the side.

Lad Tip: The biscuit crumbs are what turn this from a sweet toastie into a cheesecake toastie. Don't skip them. They provide that proper cheesecake crunch without needing to spend half the day baking a New York cheesecake the size of a paving slab.

Get the free weekly recipe + weekend challenge.

Free weekly recipe. Weekend challenge. No nonsense.

By joining, you agree to receive AF-200 Crew emails, including occasional offers or affiliate recommendations. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy.